Attracting members is great—but keeping them is where real growth happens. But before you even think about retention, it starts with choosing the right membership model that fits your audience and business goals. High retention means more predictable revenue, stronger community, and better results for everyone. In this guide, we’ll walk you through proven strategies to retain your members and minimize churn.
1. Set Clear Expectations from Day One
Why It Matters:
Most cancellations happen because people feel confused, overwhelmed, or underwhelmed. Setting clear expectations up front builds trust and reduces buyer’s remorse.
How to Do It:
-
Welcome Email Series: Send an automated sequence that introduces your offer, explains how to get started, and outlines what to expect.
-
Orientation Video: Create a short “Start Here” video showing how to navigate your platform and what results members can expect.
-
Onboarding Checklist: Give them small wins right away—like completing their profile, watching the first lesson, or joining the community.
When people feel guided and supported from day one, they’re far less likely to bounce.
2. Deliver Quick Wins Early
The Psychology:
New members are most excited—and most vulnerable—in their first 7–14 days, a concept known in psychology as the “honeymoon phase” of user onboarding. Give them a quick win during this window and they’ll feel they made the right decision.
Ideas for Quick Wins:
-
A mini challenge to complete in the first week.
-
A “Get Results Fast” section in your course or dashboard.
-
A resource vault that helps them solve a small but urgent problem immediately.
When members experience early success, they’re more likely to stay, engage, and trust your long-term process.
3. Build a Real Community
Why Community is a Retention Superpower:
People don’t just stay for the content—they stay for the connections. A strong community fosters accountability, motivation, and belonging, which aligns with what Richard Millington from FeverBee calls “emotional investment” in online groups.
Tips to Build Connection:
-
Welcome new members publicly and encourage introductions.
-
Run monthly challenges or themed discussions.
-
Host live Q&A or coworking calls to create real-time interaction.
-
Use member spotlights to celebrate wins and build social proof.
A thriving community becomes the glue that keeps members sticking around—even if they fall behind on content.
4. Provide Consistent, Ongoing Value
Keep It Fresh:
Don’t let your membership feel like a static course. Keep things dynamic so members are constantly discovering new reasons to stay. Even your pricing strategy can influence retention—when members feel they’re getting more value than they’re paying for, they stick around longer.
What You Can Offer:
-
Monthly or bi-weekly content drops or workshops.
-
Regular live coaching calls or expert interviews.
-
Fresh templates, swipe files, or case studies.
-
Curated resources or industry updates.
If your members can consistently answer “What’s new this month?”—you’re on the right track.
5. Ask for Feedback & Act on It
Create a Feedback Loop:
Your members are the best source of ideas to improve your offer—and gathering customer feedback is a pillar of Lean Startup methodology. Ask them what’s working, what’s confusing, and what they’d love to see next.
How to Collect Feedback:
-
Simple polls in your community.
-
Quarterly surveys.
-
Anonymous feedback forms.
-
Live call Q&As.
Then—actually implement what they say. When people feel heard, they feel loyal.
6. Address Cancellation Before It Happens
Be Proactive, Not Reactive:
Don’t wait until someone cancels to ask why. Build systems that detect disengagement early.
Warning Signs of At-Risk Members:
-
They haven’t logged in for a while.
-
They skip live calls or stop posting.
-
They didn’t complete onboarding steps.
What You Can Do:
-
Send re-engagement emails.
-
Reach out personally if your membership is small.
-
Offer “pause” options instead of canceling.
-
Create a “Win-Back” email sequence with bonuses, check-ins, or mini-challenges.
Retention is easier than re-acquisition—fight to keep every member.
7. Celebrate Progress and Milestones
Why It Works:
Recognition creates emotion—and emotion leads to loyalty. Celebrate even the smallest wins to keep members excited and connected.
Ideas to Celebrate Members:
-
“Member of the Month” shoutouts.
-
Completion badges or digital trophies.
-
Milestone emails (“Congrats on finishing Module 1!”)
-
Surprise bonuses or handwritten notes.
Make people feel seen. When you reward progress, you reinforce staying power.
Final Thoughts
Retention isn’t about locking people in—it’s about delivering value so compelling, they want to stay. Here’s a quick recap:
✅ Set clear expectations with onboarding.
✅ Deliver quick wins within the first week.
✅ Build a connected, supportive community.
✅ Keep your content and events fresh.
✅ Listen to feedback and adapt.
✅ Spot disengaged members and re-engage them.
✅ Celebrate member milestones to fuel loyalty.
When you master retention, your membership becomes more than a product—it becomes a place people belong.
How are you keeping members engaged right now? Share your tips or struggles below!
Ready to create a membership your audience never wants to leave?
Check out Stu McLaren’s Membership Experience Course—your blueprint for building, growing, and retaining a thriving community.
Click here to learn more